Much like my scrawling teenage penmanship has degraded over 25 years of typing on computers, so too have halt and record progress in a game faded away. I attribute this to the rise of autosave, checkpoints, console quick-resume features, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I instinctively save constantly in case things blow up. But I’m not perfect. I get lazy. Recently, I discovered a crucial piece of wisdom after significant time invested in the newly ported Pokémon FireRed on Nintendo's console: you still gotta manually hit save.
It had been years since I picked up one of the 2D Pokémon games — having missed the boat on the GBA era, 2000’s Pokémon Gold and Silver probably were the most recent traditional Pokémon journey I completed. Consequently, I was thrilled to spend the asking price for the nostalgic return back to Kanto, and an attempt collecting those original 151 Pokémon. I quickly returned to a simpler time. During a handful of gaming sessions, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, picked up an early Pikachu, beat Brock with ease, gambled on buying the Magikarp from the salesman in the Pokémon Center, and traversed Mt. Moon completely unconcerned.
The fatal flaw: Not once did I save! And never thought to.
Jigglypuff will never find love with that Mankey.
Everything went wrong on a night where I didn’t play FireRed… and where my kid picked up the Switch for a quick half-hour of the newer Pokémon title in its place, quitting my application to do so. As any Switch user understands (as I should have known…) opening a new game on the system closes your current game. Your data is only preserved when an autosave triggers or after a manual save ahead of launching something else. Oops.
The Development of Save Systems: From Manual to Automatic
It's fair to consider automatic saving, now so invisible most players barely notice it, as a bona fide “next-generation” innovation. While PC text adventure Zork implemented a pioneering save systems in gaming, the 1986 Zelda title is widely hailed as a pivotal point for not feeling completely screwed by an in-game fail thanks to persistent memory saves on NES cartridges. Of course, the responsibility remained to save. (And after one flub), you’d never forget. In that decade, save cards for systems like PlayStation normalized the save process but remained precarious; failing to save (or having a card corrupt) could wipe hours of progress. Titles such as Resident Evil went so far as to make saving into a limited resource.
Contemporary background saving, that eroded my natural saving reflex my retro gaming session so effectively, took hold around the turn of the millennium. The original Halo pioneered seamless respawn points as the Call of Duty series honed the approach to smooth difficulty and reduce tedious replay. As game worlds expanded — and more open-world — devs cracked the code of persistent, invisible saving and, in time, the ultimate convenience of picking up exactly where you left off.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Curiously, the Pokémon series offers a clear snapshot of that historical progression. For a long time, preserving your Pokédex progress was a deliberate choice: players were trained to hit “Save” ahead of powering down their device. The shift began with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the games added an autosave feature (which players could turn off), signaling a significant design shift for a franchise known as slowest-changing series.
I can admit failure: Countless hours spent in Breath of the Wild and modern Mario games completely dulled my manual save reflex. I am still wary with certain games — I won’t even gamble exiting prematurely in a challenging indie title despite being aware it has a robust save system — but whether it’s been too long since I sank time classic gaming mechanics, or modern conveniences have softened me, it didn’t even occur to me to manually save when I stopped playing. The child I once was would not have made such a mistake this badly.
The Consequences: A Discouraged Player
I have not opened FireRed since my save debacle. When I saw the title screen again to see I had only the beginning Squirtle, a wave of exhaustion hit me. The verdict: Burned.
I might give it another shot… or maybe I’ll stick with the countless modern titles released constantly which gently presume I need my hand held. Nevertheless, my affection for classic games remains alive. During times I can distract my daughter away from auto-saving Pokémon Legends: Z-A, we have been cooperatively playing Switch 2’s Super Bomberman Collection. Those classic titles omitted saving entirely in favor of old-school passwords. Thus, when I blow myself up, it’s not a total loss. That provides some small solace.